@Courtesy of Apple Original Films
Doug Liman must be a filmmaker with an iron will. Even though over the years he has clashed in one way or another with half of Hollywood Studios, reaping in some cases thunderous failures with audiences and critics, he continues undaunted to put forward his ironic, almost irreverent idea of mainstream cinema. Just a few weeks after the release of Road House for Amazon Studios – let us recall that even then Liman openly clashed with the company which preferred to place the action starring Jake Gyllenhaal straight to the streaming platform instead of the theatrical release – here comes The Instigators for Apple TV+, another action comedy starring Matt Damon, Casey Affleck, Hong Chau, Michael Stuhlbarg, Alfred Molina, Ron Perlman, and Toby Jones. No less than an impressive all-star cast.
The story of this movie revolves around two small-time criminals, Rory (Damon) and Cobby (Affleck) who, after attempting a botched robbery against the Mayor of Boston, find themselves pursued by trigger-happy police and the very criminals who commissioned the “heist.” The only person willing to help them is surprisingly Donna (Chau), Rory’s psychotherapist…
As often happens, perhaps too often the case in Liman’s cinema, the screenplay of The Instigators is little more than a canvas, a plot thread that serves to barely hold together funny scenes and situations in which the characters can peck at each other, exposing those differences that on the contrary conceal perhaps deeper ties. Here then, amid such, obvious narrative paucity we are nevertheless amused to see Matt Damon and Casey Affleck acting as if they were Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau, or rather a decidedly “proletarian” version of the buddy-movie couple/style. When a trio is later formed with the addition of Hong Chau, the comic tone of The Instigators even goes up a notch, offering audiences entertainment that is undoubtedly light but no less effective.
It is really too bad that the screenplay almost completely forgets to develop the side characters besides the three main roles, not only in psychological definition but even in the narrative journey. So it happens that the film literally loses Michael Stuhlbarg and Alfred Molina along the way, those who leave the scene in such a lame way after being hilarious on at least a couple of occasions. Even worse is the cinematic fate of Paul Walter Hauser, whose character appears in practically only one sequence only to be swallowed up by the oblivion of a script that offers very little logical sense for the approximately 100 minutes of the film’s duration.
@Courtesy of Apple Original Films
Set exclusively in “their” Boston, The Instigators deserves to be watched almost exclusively to see Matt Damon and Casey Affleck acting together again, two first-class actors who prove that they know each other’s tones and especially their timing. Their constant bickering results in a wacky, almost farcical guilty pleasure that fits nicely into a popular setting that makes for sparkling staging. The rest is, as it almost always happens when it comes to Doug Liman, jaunty cinema that rests entirely on tone and pace.
A formula that is certainly risky because of its lacking foundation, but also capable in some cases of offering a spectacle that is not predictable, or rather not subservient to the established canons of contemporary Hollywood entertainment. Liman continues to give a damn about working narrative structures, choosing instead to rely on editing and tone as the primary focus of his films. A formula that, even when it hits the mark, never manages to work in depth. But at least he knows how to deliver products that are not predictable and have their own iconoclastic, dare we say rebellious streak. The Instigators, almost making the most of its striking fragility, certainly falls into this (small) group of feature films.
Rate: C+
If you like the articles, share your thoughts below!
Check out more of Adriano’s articles.
Here’s the trailer for The Instigators: