@Courtesy of Peacock
Ever since its first real U.S. box office success Universal Soldier, back in 1992, with Roland Emmerich it has always been take it or leave it. His idea of suave, over-the-top, ultra-spectacular mise-en-scène has decreed his greatest successes like Independence Day or 2012. You got the idea, right? A “trademark” that the German filmmaker has consistently reproduced regardless of the size of the budget available, reaching peaks of “kitsch” that few other directors have been able to achieve in modern times.
So why change strategy when it comes to a television series? Especially if the basic idea is to resurrect the unabashedly hyperbolic and bloody “peplum” of Rome, the original HBO show that reached considerable success starting in 2005. Created by Robert Rodat (Oscar nominee for the screenplay of Saving Private Ryan) Those About to Die reveals itself from the pilot to be an extremely free-form revival in both content and staging, both developed to create a type of show that is anything but committed or demanding: in the development of the various plots that weave in the intrigues of power we can find that agility aimed at those who want to enjoy a quick and whimsical product instead of a series with layered characters and emotional situations. This is the way Emmerich develops on these narratives his lithe aesthetic, even frivolous when it comes to characterizing the different roles. This makes Those About to Die a wildly paced show, something one is almost not used to seeing in contemporary “adult” seriality anymore.
@Courtesy of Peacock
The result is objectively disappointing, especially in the first episode, while the second episode contains some ideas and a couple of moments that make it more interesting. Overall, however, the show offers far too little dramatic quality to be fully convincing: since what matters most seems to be the rhythm of the storytelling and the spectacle of the action scenes, the actors must necessarily try to fill roles that are evidently difficult to characterize in a substantial way in the face of such a mayhem of actions and events.
The only one with whom one can enter into a minimum of interest, perhaps even feel some empathy, is the Tenax played with charisma by Iwan Rheon (Game of Thrones, Vicious), while all the others unravel too superficially to truly get into the audience’s good graces. Even a great actor like two-time Academy Award winner Sir Anthony Hopkins, who is also beginning to show the burden of an advanced age, cannot get beyond a rough characterization of the emperor who rules Rome and its fortunes in the first few episodes.
For a certain television audience accustomed to some kind of characters’ development, situations, and atmospheres capable of engaging, even taking their time over the course of a single episode or even an entire season, Those About to Die is certainly not a type of product that we would recommend. If instead what one wants to get out of a show is an hour of mindless entertainment, centered on the splendor of the distant (and mythologized) setting and the pace of exposition, that gives no rest from the fury of intrigue, twists and spectacular action, perhaps Rodat and Emmerich’s series might even entertain.
We frankly did not feel a spasmodic need for another serial “peplum” that works only on the surface: it is undeniable that Emmerich knows how to build his carousels by creating a baroque and reckless aesthetic universe, assembled each time by a raging montage. In the same way, however, the days of Independence Day and especially The Day After Tomorrow – in our opinion his “masterpiece” precisely because it possessed characters with some depth and an effective plot beyond the wonder of the special effects – seem to be past, and the filmmaker also seems to keep exploiting a trademark that, unsupported by the appropriate means to express itself to the fullest, shows signs of a certain wear and tear. Indeed, it has been showing them for some time now, as Those About to Die simply comes to reaffirm it….
@Courtesy of Peacock
Rate: D
If you like the articles, share your thoughts below!
Check out more of Adriano’s articles.
Here’s the trailer of Those About to Die: